Will Cliff Lee Be A Yankee Tonight? No

Written by: Drew Sarver on 9th July 2010

Will Cliff Lee Be A Yankee Tonight? No | read this item

Update 5:20 pm Cliff Lee will be a Texas Ranger. That according to Joel Sherman and Buster Olney. Lee will be headed to Texas for “star in the making” Justin Smoak, and three prospects (Blake Beavan, Josh Lueke, Matt Lawson). The Rangers also get reliever Mark Lowe.

It’s a hefty to price to pay for Rangers’ GM Jon Daniels. He’s giving up a player who they view as an annual 30-40 home run hitter for a three month rental. Evidently Daniels is worried about the pending bankruptcy of the team and may feel this is the Rangers lone shot at a title.

But it also makes me think of a 2006 Rangers deal. Adrian Gonzalez, Chris Young, and Termel Sledge for Aki Otsuka and Adam Eaton”.

Now Cliff Lee is a much better pitcher than Eaton or Otsuka, the latter of which was to fill the closer role at the time. But Gonzalez was a can’t miss prospect and he has proven all the scouts right. Smoak may make Daniels regret this deal as well.

The Yankees and Mariners had agreed to deal in principle that would have sent Jesus Montero, David Adams, and Zach McAllister to Seattle, but the Mariners decided to look for a better off. They certainly got one.

* * *

With all of the hoopla (pun very much intended) over LeBron James last night, I was shocked to see he was not the subject of conversation on Twitter this morning. No sooner had my computer booted up then my brain got a jolt as well. The NY Post’s Joel Sherman reported that the Yankees are in deep conversations with the Seattle Mariners for Cliff Lee.

Say what?

By 10 a.m. Sherman had tweeted and written that the teams were on the brink of getting the deal done. Jesus Montero, the Yankees number one prospect, would be the centerpiece of the trade. Montero has struggled at the plate for much of his first full season at Triple-A, but is still highly regarded around baseball. This would also indicate that the Yankees front office is higher on catching prospect Austin Romine for the future.

The Mariners are also said to be intereted in 2nd base prospect, and UVA product, David Adams. Sherman says a third prospect will also be included in the deal.

With Lee’s free agency on the horizon, you have to wonder if the Yankees will demand a window to negotiate a long term deal with the prized left-hander. Though the Yankees would be giving up prospects, acquiring Lee would preclude losing draft picks if Lee went elsewhere and the Yankees then signed him as a free agent.

Some feel this deal would be overkill since the Yankees roll out CC Sabathia, A.J. Burnett, Andy Pettitte, Phil Hughes, and Javier Vazquez on a regular basis. Though three of the pitchers are All-Stars, Hughes has an innings limit and Burnett and Vazquez have struggled at times. It’s possible once he nears the innings limit, Hughes could bolster the bullpen for the remainder of the season as he did last year.

While there are mixed feelings about giving up a top prospect, Cliff Lee is the type of player you give him up for.

Update: 11:20 am ESPN’s Buster Olney tweeted that since Lee is set to face them tonight, the Yankees told the Mariners they have to have answer soon.

Joel Sherman has now reported that the Yankees will not ask for a negotiating window to get a long term deal done with Lee.

Update: 3:45 pm Sherman says the deal is off – he just tweeted:
“To repeat the Yankees aren’t getting Cliff Lee. Mariners concerned about David Adams ankle plus apparently another team has jumped in hard.”

Update: 4:20 pm According to several people involved with the Yankees, the deal is definitely dead (for now) with Seattle.

It look the Texas Rangers are the team that has re-entered the fray. Rangers’ Hall of Fame beat writer T.R. Sullivan says “…the Rangers won’t do (Justin) Smoak”. Possibilities are Jared Saltalamacchia, Engel Beltre, Derek Holland, Omar Beltre and Blake Beavan.

Stay tuned for updates.

Share on Tumblr

Topics: Adam Eaton, adrian gonzalez, andy pettitte, austin romine, Blake Beavan, bullpen, Buster Olney, cc sabathia, Centerpiece, Chris Young, draft picks, ESPN, Free Agent, Home Run Hitter, Hoopla, James Last, javier vazquez, jesus montero, Joel Sherman, Jolt, Justin Smoak, LeBron James, Left Hander, mark lowe, Mixed Feelings, Montero, Ny Post, Otsuka, Phil Hughes, Seattle Mariners, Termel Sledge, Texas Ranger, Zach McAllister